Introduction
Prescriptive process models are traditional software development models that follow a structured and well-defined sequence of steps. They prescribe a strict approach to software development, ensuring predictability, discipline, and organization in the development process. These models are useful for projects that require well-documented and sequential progress.
Key Characteristics of Prescriptive Models
- Linear and sequential approach (Step-by-step execution)
- Well-defined phases (Planning, design, development, testing, deployment)
- Strict documentation and planning
- Less flexibility to changes
- Best suited for well-understood projects with clear requirements
Types of Prescriptive Process Models
1. Waterfall Model
Definition:
The Waterfall Model is the simplest prescriptive process model, where the software development process flows sequentially through well-defined phases.
Phases of Waterfall Model:
- Requirement Analysis – Collect and document customer requirements.
- System Design – Define architecture, modules, and components.
- Implementation (Coding) – Convert design into actual code.
- Testing – Verify functionality and fix errors.
- Deployment – Release the software to users.
- Maintenance – Fix bugs and enhance the system after deployment.
Advantages:
✔ Simple and easy to manage
✔ Works well for small projects with well-defined requirements
✔ Ensures proper documentation
Disadvantages:
✘ Not suitable for complex or evolving projects
✘ Late testing phase can lead to costly bug fixes
✘ No feedback loop, making changes difficult
2. V-Model (Verification and Validation Model)
Definition:
The V-Model is an extension of the Waterfall Model where every development phase has a corresponding testing phase, forming a V-shaped structure.
Phases of V-Model:
- Requirement Analysis → Acceptance Testing
- System Design → System Testing
- High-Level Design → Integration Testing
- Low-Level Design → Unit Testing
- Implementation (Coding)
Advantages:
✔ Early detection of defects due to parallel testing
✔ Suitable for projects requiring high reliability (e.g., medical and safety-critical systems)
Disadvantages:
✘ Still rigid and does not handle changes well
✘ Requires strong planning for testing activities
3. Prototyping Model
Definition:
In the Prototyping Model, an initial prototype (a working version) of the software is built and refined through multiple iterations based on user feedback.
Phases of Prototyping Model:
- Requirement Gathering – Collect initial requirements.
- Quick Design – Create a basic system structure.
- Prototyping – Develop a working prototype.
- User Evaluation – Get feedback from users.
- Refinement – Improve the prototype based on feedback.
- Final Development – Convert the refined prototype into a full system.
Advantages:
✔ Helps in understanding user needs early
✔ Reduces risk of failure by incorporating feedback
✔ Suitable for complex and innovative applications
Disadvantages:
✘ Can lead to scope creep (project requirements keep changing)
✘ Time-consuming and may increase development cost
4. Incremental Model
Definition:
The Incremental Model divides the software development process into smaller, manageable parts (increments). Each increment adds new functionality to the software.
Phases of Incremental Model:
- Requirement Analysis – Identify core functionalities.
- Design & Development (for first increment) – Develop and test the first version.
- Deployment & Feedback – Deliver the first version to users.
- Repeat for Next Increments – Improve and add more features in subsequent cycles.
Advantages:
✔ Faster delivery of functional software
✔ Easier to test and debug small increments
✔ Allows changes in later stages
Disadvantages:
✘ Requires careful planning and integration
✘ May become expensive if too many increments are needed
5. Spiral Model
Definition:
The Spiral Model combines elements of the Waterfall and Prototyping models while focusing on risk management. It is used for large, complex projects where risk assessment is crucial.
Phases of Spiral Model:
- Planning – Define objectives, risks, and requirements.
- Risk Analysis – Identify potential risks and develop solutions.
- Development & Testing – Implement the solution and test it.
- Review & Refinement – Evaluate the current iteration and plan the next phase.
- Repeat for Each Spiral (Iteration)
Advantages:
✔ Best for high-risk, large-scale projects
✔ Allows changes and feedback at early stages
✔ Helps in reducing project failure risks
Disadvantages:
✘ Expensive and complex to implement
✘ Requires highly skilled developers for risk assessment
Comparison of Prescriptive Models
| Feature | Waterfall | V-Model | Prototyping | Incremental | Spiral |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Flexibility | Low | Low | High | Medium | High |
| User Involvement | Low | Low | High | Medium | High |
| Risk Management | Low | Medium | Low | Medium | High |
| Best For | Small projects | Critical systems | UI-based software | Medium-large projects | Large, high-risk projects |
Conclusion
Prescriptive process models provide structured approaches to software development. While they ensure discipline and organization, they may not always be flexible enough for modern, rapidly changing projects. Choosing the right model depends on factors like project size, risk level, complexity, and user involvement.
4o